Skip to content
Rim CountryInsider

History

Rim Country History and Museums: Zane Grey, Pioneer Towns and Ancient Villages

Rim Country’s history runs from a village of 79 stone structures near Payson, occupied a thousand years ago, to a military road along the edge of the Mogollon Rim, Mormon pioneer towns, a deadly range feud and the novelist who wrote about it. Here’s where to see that history in person, with hours and seasons for each stop.

The short version

  • Open year-round: the Rim Country Museum and Zane Grey Cabin in Payson (Thursday to Saturday), Shoofly Village (daily, free) and Tonto Natural Bridge’s Goodfellow Lodge.
  • Spring to fall only: the Pine-Strawberry Museum and the Strawberry Schoolhouse, both closed for winter.
  • On your own, any time the roads are open: the General Crook Trail along the Rim.

Rim Country Museum and the Zane Grey Cabin (Payson)

The Northern Gila County Historical Society runs the museum and cabin at 700 S. Green Valley Parkway, next to Green Valley Park. According to Arizona Highways, the main exhibit hall is a replica of Payson’s Herron Hotel, which burned in 1918, and the grounds include the area’s first district ranger’s office and residence.

Zane Grey and Rim Country

Western novelist Zane Grey first came to the Rim in 1918. By 1921 he had a hunting lodge about 17 miles east of Payson, near Tonto Creek, and he came back most autumns until 1929. Bill Goettl restored the cabin in 1963 and ran it as a private museum until the 1990 Dude Fire destroyed it. The original site is now gated private land, so the Zane Grey Cabin Foundation built the replica in Payson, using local ponderosa pine and some of the original foundation and chimney stone, and it was dedicated in 2005.

According to the museum, Grey wrote 23 books set in Arizona, 13 of them about the Payson area. It suggests starting with Under the Tonto Rim, To the Last Man, The Drift Fence, The Hash Knife Outfit and the Tonto Basin section of Tales of Lonely Trails. To the Last Man (1922) draws on the Pleasant Valley War.

Shoofly Village (near Payson)

Off Houston Mesa Road northeast of Payson, the Tonto National Forest’s Shoofly Village is what remains of a settlement of 79 structures occupied from about A.D. 1000 to 1250. The rock outlines of the walls are still visible. It’s one of two prehistoric sites on the Tonto with an interpretive trail, and the Forest Service lists it as accessible. A brochure from the Friends of the Tonto National Forest says the people who lived here had close ties to the Hohokam and Salado cultures but developed a culture of their own. It’s open for day use, 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., with no fee and no water. Please leave everything as you find it; it’s a protected archaeological site.

Pine-Strawberry Museum (Pine)

The Pine Strawberry Archaeological & Historical Society’s museum, at 3886 N. Highway 87, has been open since the 1970s. Its main room was once an LDS chapel and community school, and the collection covers Mormon settlement, early schooling, World War II, farm tools and pottery from a local excavation. Admission is $1 for adults and free for kids 11 and under. It runs on a volunteer schedule in spring, summer and fall and is closed for the winter; check pinestrawhs.org for the current season.

Pine itself dates to 1879, when Mormon families moved to Pine Creek from Mazatzal City. See our Pine guide for more.

Strawberry Schoolhouse (Strawberry)

According to its National Register nomination, construction on this one-room log schoolhouse began in early 1885 and classes started that fall. It closed in 1916, when enrollment dropped below eight students, and by 1959 only the walls were left. The historical society restored it in 1979 and 1980 and opened it to the public in 1981, on its original site. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2005, and the society calls it Arizona’s oldest standing schoolhouse.

It’s at 9318 W. Fossil Creek Road, 1.75 miles west of SR 87. Free tours run from mid-May to mid-October, so it’s closed for the winter.

The General Crook Trail (on the Rim)

In 1871, Gen. George Crook scouted a route along the edge of the Mogollon Rim to move troops and supplies quickly during his campaign to force Apache and Yavapai people onto reservations. Work began in 1872, and the first wagon train ran from Fort Whipple to Fort Apache in 1874. The road stayed in use until the Rim Road was built in 1928.

Today it’s a National Historic Trail. In the early 1970s, Boy Scouts retraced the route and marked it with metal chevrons, which still mark the way. Trailheads include one next to the Mogollon Rim Visitor Center on SR 260. The Military Sinkhole Trail climbs to a sinkhole that was a camp on Crook’s road. See our guide to the Rim for trails and seasons.

The Pleasant Valley War (Young)

South of the Rim, in Pleasant Valley around the town of Young, the feud between the Graham and Tewksbury families turned deadly. According to the Sharlot Hall Museum, 13 people died in about four months at its peak in 1887, more than 30 died in all, and no one was ever convicted in a territorial court. A historical marker stands in front of the museum in Young, on State Route 288, and some of the feud’s victims are buried in the Young cemetery.

The Tonto Apache Tribe

Apache and Yavapai people lived in this country long before the settlers. In 1875, the federal government forced about 1,450 of them from the Verde Valley to the San Carlos reservation, a march on which, according to the National Park Service, at least 100 people died. Ninety-seven years later, in 1972, the Tonto Apache Reservation was created on 85 acres of national forest land at Payson. In 2015 the federal government added about 292 acres, bringing it to more than 375 acres.

More history to find

For more ideas, see things to do in Rim Country.