Pine and Strawberry pack a lot of good stops into a few miles of Highway 87: a brewpub, wood-fired pizza, small-town diners and taverns, Italian dinners in a historic lodge, a farm cafe and plenty of fudge and ice cream. Here’s where to eat in both towns. We checked each place in November 2026 against the Pine Strawberry Business Community’s 2026 map and the businesses’ own sites; hours are often seasonal here, so call ahead, especially in winter. Each name links to its listing in our directory.
Pine
- THAT Brewery & Pub: a brewpub pouring its own beers, including Arizona Trail Ale, with smoked meats from the kitchen and a family- and dog-friendly patio with yard games.
- Old County Inn: wood-fired pizza, appetizers and cocktails made from scratch, with a dog-friendly patio and an adjoining taproom.
- The Early Bird Cafe: a small-town diner on Highway 87 with home-style breakfast and lunch.
- Pinewood Tavern: a neighborhood tavern on Hardscrabble Mesa Road with burgers, smoked pork and live music on many weekends.
- Old County Burger: a casual burger spot on Hardscrabble Mesa Road, in the old Pine Deli building.
- Uncle Tom’s Pizza & Hot Stuff: pizza, subs and burgers at the food counter inside Uncle Tom’s station.
Sweets in Pine
- Pine Creek Fudge & Espresso: fudge made on site, ice cream, espresso and breakfast sandwiches.
- Gingerbread House: hand-dipped ice cream in fresh waffle cones at an antique and gift shop in a historic building.
- Elky’s Soft Serve: soft serve, fresh lemonade and specialty hot dogs from a truck at the Rusty Pine Cone; likely seasonal.
Strawberry
- The Strawberry Lodge: Italian dinners and a full bar in the historic lodge on Fossil Creek Road.
- Mamajoe’s Italian Grill: family-run Italian with pasta, pizza, steaks and seafood and a full bar, across Highway 87 from the Strawberry Inn.
- Bandits Restaurant & The Dirty Cowboy Saloon: burgers, wings and comfort food, with karaoke and live music nights.
- Sportsman’s Chalet: bison and elk burgers, a Friday fish fry and pool tables.
- Fossil Creek Farm: a cafe on a working farm on Fossil Creek Road, with breakfasts, light lunches and goats.
- PIEbar AZ: handmade sweet and savory empanadas and coffee from a food trailer on Highway 87.
- Windmill Coffee: a walk-up coffee window by the windmill at the Strawberry Inn.
Make a day of it
Pair a meal with Tonto Natural Bridge, a hike from the Pine Trailhead (see our hiking guide), or the Pine-Strawberry Museum and Strawberry Schoolhouse in season. See our guides to Pine and Strawberry, and where to stay if you’re spending the night.
Also see where to eat in Payson and along SR 260 and on the Rim. Own a business we missed? Add it to the directory for free.